2008 - Nick Baldetti, Wayne State
2007 - Dane Todd, Nebraska
             Greg Wilmes, Dana
2006 - Blake Tiedtke, Nebraska
2005 - Dusty Keiser, Nebraska
          
Randall Hopkins, Nebraska-Omaha
2004 - Curt Tomasevicz, Nebraska
          
Tim Clemenger, Peru State
2003 - Will Dabbert, Nebraska
          
Justin Stark, Doane
2002 - Chad Geiger, Nebraska-Omaha
          
Mike Muma, Nebraska-Kearney
2001 - Mark Pentico, Doane
          
Jake McKee, Nebraska
2000 - Adam Julch, Nebraska
          
Andy Stine, Nebraska-Omaha
          
Wayne Webster, Doane
1999 - Monte Christo, Nebraska
          
Larry Brown, Nebraska-Omaha
1998 - Chad Wiesler, Doane
1997 - David Seizys, Nebraska 
          
Scott Reynolds, Hastings
1996 - Steve Volin, Nebraska
1995 - Kevin Christiansen, Nebraska Wesleyan
          
W. LaMont Rainey, Wayne State
          
Matt Shaw, Nebraska
1994 - Troy Branch, Nebraska
          
Ryan Buckley, Hastings
          
Stephen Gaines, Peru State
1993 - Mark Fritch, Peru State
          
John McMillen, Nebraska
1992 - Dan Sellon, Nebraska-Omaha
          
George Achola, Nebraska
          
Curtis Fox, Nebraska Wesleyan
1991 - Matt Korte, Concordia
1990 - Bill Bobbora, Nebraska
          John Baumann, Doane
          James Gallentine, Hastings
1989 - Tom Welter, Nebraska
1988 - None
1987 - Chris Carr, Nebraska
          
Paul LaFond, Nebraska-Omaha
1986 - Jerry Kripal, Nebraska-Omaha
1985 - Scott Strasburger, Nebraska
1984 - Mike Tranmer, Nebraska
          
Charles Mitchell, Chadron State
          
Kirk Hutton, Nebraska-Omaha
1983 - Mike Mandelko, Nebraska
          
Greg Havelka, Nebraska-Omaha
1982 - Ric Lindquist, Nebraska
1981 - Jeff Finn, Nebraska
          
Mark Christensen, Doane
1980 - Bill Weidner, Hastings
1979 - Jim Pillen, Nebraska
1978 - Ted Harvey, Nebraska
          
Steve Bates, Kearney State
1977 - Carl Anderson III, Nebraska-Omaha
          
Duane Fritz, Chadron State
1976 - Mike Coyle, Nebraska
          
John Thomsen, Nebraska-Omaha
1975 - Dan Anderson, Nebraska
          
Marvin Beck, Nebraska-Omaha
1974 - Jeff Hill, Nebraska
          
Mike O’Holleran, Nebraska
1973 - Mike Beren, Nebraska