Recognized annually, faculty members from the Intercollegiate Athletic Committee vote upon and select one male and one female student-athlete per year. Criteria for nomination include candidates being enrolled in the academic year in which the final season of athletic eligibility occurs; having a minimum cumulative grade point average of 3.000; performing with distinction in a varsity sport; and acting, both on and off the field in a manner that has brought credit to the student-athlete, the institution and intercollegiate athletics. Traditionally, this is one of the most competitive academic awards available to student-athletes throughout the academic year.
- 1991: Lynne Frey (Track & Field) and David Edeal (Football)
- 1992: Janet Kruse (Volleyball) and Pat Engelbert (Football)
- 1993: Karen Jennings (Basketball) and Mike Stigge (Football)
- 1994: Theresa Stelling (Track/Cross Country) and Trev Alberts (Football)
- 1995: Nicole Duval (Gymnastics) and Rob Zatechka (Football)
- 1996: Billie Winsett-Fletcher (Volleyball) and Jason Christie (Gymnastics)
- 1997: Shelly Bartlett (Gymnastics) and Ted Harris (Gymnastics)
- 1998: Jenny Smith (Softball) and Ryan Tobin (Wrestling)
- 1999: Fiona Nepo (Volleyball) and Jim Koziol (Gymnastics)
- 2000: Janet Dutton (Track) and Brian Shaw (Football)
- 2001: Angie Oxley (Volleyball) and Kyle Vanden Bosch (Football)
- 2002: Diandra Hyman (Bowling) and Bryan Snyder (Wrestling)
- 2003: Laura Pilakowski (Volleyball/Basketball) and Jeff Leise (Baseball)
- 2004: Ann Gaffigan (Cross Country/Track) and Judd Davies (Football)
- 2005: Richelle Simpson (Women's Gymnastics) and Daniel Bruce (Baseball)
- 2006: Ashley Selig (Track) and Aaron Plas (Track)
- 2007: Stephanie Carter (Women's Gymnastics) and Dane Todd (Football)
- 2008: Sarah Pavan (Volleyball) and Stephen Tetrault (Men's Gymnastics)
- 2009: Amanda Gates (Volleyball) and Nick Sullivan (Baseball)
- 2010: Kelsey Griffin (Basketball) and Craig Brester (Wrestling)
- 2011: Natalie Willer (Track) and Nicholas Gordon (Track)
- 2012: Ashley Miller (Track/CC) and Tyler Hitchler (Track)
- 2013: Mary Weatherholt (Tennis) and Björn Barrefors (Track)
- 2014: Emily Wong (Gymnastics) and Seth Wiedel (Track)
- 2015: Jessie DeZiel (Gymnastics) and John Welk (Track)
- 2016: Mattie Fowler (Softball) and Shavon Shields (Basketball)
- 2017: Tierra Williams (Track and Field) and Drew Wiseman (Track and Field)
- 2018: Danielle Breen (Women's Gymnastics) and Chris Stephenson (Men's Gymnastics)
- 2019: Mikaela Foecke (Volleyball) and Anton Stephenson (Men's Gymnastics)
- 2020: Sierra Hassel (Women's Gymnastics) and Luke Siedhoff (Track and Field)
- 2021: Abigail Knapton (Swimming & Diving) and Evan Hymanson (Men's Gymnastics)
- 2022: Andy Jacobs (Track and Field) and Dylan LeClair (Men's Gymnastics)
- 2023: Ieva Turke (Track and Field) and Trent Hixson (Football)